Should you give the ring back

Homepage Forums Battle of the Sexes Should you give the ring back

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #11405
    Mask AppealMask Appeal
    Participant

    Ladies, Fellas, my question is this:

    If you ask someone to marry you and she says yes, and then weeks later she changes her mind. Should you be entitled to get your ring back?

    +11
    #11411
    Lisa LorenLisa Loren
    Participant

    If it is a gift then, I should get to keep it.

    +7
    #11466
    Isabella GonzalezIsabella Gonzalez
    Participant

    Yeah you should give it back, especially if you’re the one who called off the engagement.

    +9
    #11480
    Word SmithWord Smith
    Participant

    Shit you better give me my ring back. It’s my money and I need it now.

    +6
    #11569
    Lonnie ClantonLonnie Clanton
    Participant

    The ring is a promised contract saying YOU WILL MARRY ME . She sign the contract by taking the ring. So if she brakes the contract she should respectfully return the ring

    +7
    #11576
    AnishaRay RayAnishaRay Ray
    Participant

    I say give it back….no need to hold on to those memories

    +6
    #11595
    Wanderers PathWanderers Path
    Participant

    Formal Etiquette dictates that she should return the ring. Although most people won’t.

    You will not get full price for the ring if you attempt to pawn it, because it’s like a car…once it leaves the lot aka the store, the price will begin to drop unless the ring adheres to the ‘traditional 4 Cs: cut, clarity, carat and color.’ The highest grade in all four categories.

    +6
    #11596
    Wanderers PathWanderers Path
    Participant

    Oh…

    PS: In some states, he could possibly sue her [if he wanted to go that far in order to retrieve the ring].
    Some states have laws on the books pertaining to the promise of marriage as a verbal contract and the ring is considered personal/private property as part of the aforementioned agreement.

    Depending on ‘where’ you live. My advice, always seek legal counsel for such matters.

    +7
    #11653
    Sky RobertsSky Roberts
    Participant

    You guys all make great points, but I actually surprisingly disagree. I dont think that the guy should ask for it back. Now if he ask for it, I will give it back, but I just think that based on the fact that he gave it to you, he shouldn’t give it back. If what you felt in the moment was genuine, then you should ask for it back.

    +4
    #11697
    Omar RodgersOmar Rodgers
    Participant

    im not giving her nothing back. Whenever females propose to me they should already know how I get down.

    +2
    #11761
    Alex SmartAlex Smart
    Participant

    I wouldnt ask for it back. I would completely leave it up to her to make that decision.

    +2
    #11773
    Lashawn WilliamstonLashawn Williamston
    Participant

    @Omar ???

    0
    #12112
    Lisa LorenLisa Loren
    Participant

    I’m sorry, but like I said I’m keeping it. it was a gift.

    0
    #14538
    Larry GeorgeLarry George
    Participant

    Give it back! We wouldn’t you give it back if we never got married.

    0
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Copyright © 2021 - Wordfencing - All Rights Reserved.     Terms and Conditions